The Challenge for New York

Access to a wider range of low- and zero-carbon- emissions fuels is a critical part of the solution

We support the goal of reducing carbon emissions in order to reduce the terrible impact of climate change. To that end, our legislators and the governor need to know that the path we’re traveling is too narrow to give us confidence that we’ll be able to do that.

We don’t have to look at the recent disasters in New Orleans, California and Texas to convince us that our electric grid is already fragile. The U.S. Energy Information Administration recently found that Americans are facing the longest total annual power outages they’ve ever recorded.*

The New York Independent System Operator (NYISO) recently released its Comprehensive Reliability Plan (CRP), concluding that the state’s bulk power system can meet reliability criteria through 2030 based on demand during normal weather. But the ability to maintain this reliability decreases if planned generation and transmission projects are delayed, if power generation sites are deactivated — or if extreme weather conditions occur.

Historically, New York’s most newsworthy—and massive—blackouts have taken place in the summer. The biggest ones—with various causes—in recent years include 2003 (50 million people throughout the Northeast), 2006 (Queens), 2012 (Superstorm Sandy), 2019 (ConEd relay protection system failure).

We saw the same type of widespread power outage in Buffalo on Christmas Eve, 2022. An overburdened electric grid couldn’t handle the demand after a massive winter storm, leaving millions without power. Dozens lost their lives. What will happen if millions of people are all running heat pumps in January and there are tens of thousands of new electric vehicles as well?

This is the direction we’re moving in now, and it needs to change.

*Source: https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=50316#

Even environmental groups like NRDC.org point out that scaling up renewables to hit 70 percent less than ten years will require a massive amount of new clean generation to come online between now and then.*

Jeff St. John points out, in a 2021 article in GTM, that this massive gap is going to be all the more challenging to fill, since “more than half of the state’s carbon-free emissions today come from nuclear power.” To make matters worse, the Indian Point nuclear power plant went off line in April 31, 2021. New York has struggled to make up for this capacity as political disagreements delay hydropower projects.

Counting on wind and solar to make up the difference? Right now, they collectively make up approximately 6% of New York’s net generation. They are also least effective at producing electricity in the winter.

*Source: https://www.nrdc.org/experts/cullen-howe/new-york-lays-down-gauntlet-renewable-energy

[NOTE: Dual Fuel means Gas/Oil, as in systems that can switch from one fuel to the other, depending on which fuel is more readily available.]

Can we really trust this process?

While advocates try to argue that the grid can be made renewable fairly quickly, and have various plans to make it so, they rely on many things going right, and a huge amount of new infrastructure investment that can’t come from Washington alone. And when in your lifetime has anything rushed so fast with so much money at stake ever gone right?

Let Albany know we need a more diverse energy solution

NYSERDA and NY utility companies have launched a whopping $10 million campaign to try to convince people that converting their entire house to heat pumps is a good idea.* That’s because people in northern climates like NY don’t like Heat Pumps when it gets cold- no matter what the “technical experts” say. To stay warm, people overwhelmingly rely on a backup energy source- like a propane gas, natural gas or heating oil unit.

A study conducted in neighboring Massachusetts showed that 9 out of 10 people who have converted to a heat pump keep their existing heating system (heating oil, natural gas, etc.) as a backup. And for good reason—83% were unhappy with their heat pump’s performance in very cold weather.* In fact, a recent article in the Boston Globe lamented that while plans called for replacing 100,000 fossil fuel systems a year with Heat Pumps, homeowners had completely converted less than 500 through 9 months of 2021- despite significant incentives.

Plus, the cost alone to convert from another heating source to an electric heat pump can top $21,000. That’s guaranteed to make you shiver even more. Read more.

*Source: https://www.nyserda.ny.gov/About/Newsroom/2021-Announcements/2021-04-12-NYS-Clean-Heat-Members-Announce-Nearly-10-Million-Consumer-Education-and-Awareness-Campaign-to-Accelerate-Adoption-of-Clean-Heating-and-Cooling-Solutions-that-Combat-Climate-Change

Take Action!

It’s not too late for a shift in the plan! Speak up NOW and let your legislators know this is not the only way. All you have to do is click below to let your voice be heard.

Take Action Today!

Missing Out on Diversifying Our Energy Sources

Alternatively, improvements in the renewable content of traditional fossil fuels coupled with increased efficiency of their equipment allow us to reduce carbon output faster and with less extraordinary expense on infrastructure.

It’s time to recognize that trying to be perfect is the enemy of being good. Fuels like Propane Gas, Natural Gas and Heating Oil have an important practical role to play in the decarbonization process.

Propane Gas

  • In comparison to a few other widely used fuels, propane is one of the lowest in carbon emissions per million BTUs.*
  • Propane produces 43% fewer greenhouse gas emissions than using an equivalent amount of electricity generated from the national electric grid.**
  • The U.S. Department of Energy classifies it as a clean alternative fuel.
  • Even electrification advocates admit electrifying everything nationally will take over 20 years and cost about $20-$25 trillion. By replacing heavy carbon engines and appliances, clean and renewable energy like propane can accelerate decarbonization today.

Renewable Propane Gas

While it is not in common use yet, renewable propane gas is positioned to be a major part of the fuel conversation in the coming months and years. Sporting ultra low carbon intensity, it is created in the same process as biodiesel, from animal fats, biomass, plant matter, etc. Because it is molecularly identical to propane gas, the two can be blended together to work in existing systems without huge conversion costs.

Sadly, research and innovation into this sustainable product will not continue if Albany stifles innovation in a rush to electrify everything.

Learn more about propane gas and renewable propane gas today!

  • Natural gas is described by the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) as an “efficient, relatively clean burning, and economical energy source.”
  • According to the International Energy Agency (IEA), natural gas offers a flexibility that makes it “a good fit for the rise of variable renewables such as wind and solar [photovoltaics].”
  • In colder climates, natural gas will keep you warmer than electric heat for less money, plain and simple.

Weighing Your Options

The argument for natural gas over electric heat in colder climates has even been covered in popular consumer media, like MarthaStewart.com. In “Gas Versus Electric Heat: Which One is Better for Your Home?” Trane Residential partner and home renovator Anthony Carrino said, “for those living in colder climates that experiences freezing or subfreezing temperatures, a new gas furnace with a higher Annual Fuel Utilization Efficiency (AFUE) rating would be recommended.”

  • Heating oil has already reduced its sulfur content in NY from 5000ppm to 15ppm. Now, it can also be combined with renewable biodiesel to create renewable biofuel.
  • Starting in 2018, NY had a mandate to blend at least 5% biodiesel into all heating oil sold in the state. However, biofuel with 20% blend is already sold widely, and fuel companies have been delivering biofuel blends of up to 40%.
  • Biodiesel can be made from organic and recycled matter, including soybean oil, used cooking oils, inedible corn, canola, fats and algae.
  • Use does not require modification of existing heating systems, so biofuels can immediately reduce carbon footprint at a fraction of the cost of electrification.
  • Biofuel is a U.S.-made product. When you use it to heat your home, you support American farmers, energy producers and sellers!

Learn more about Bioheat® fuel today!

This is too important to ignore!

Speak up for your energy future and make your voice heard TODAY!

Take Action Today!

Do you know how much of the energy required to produce electricity is actually lost in conversion?

According to the U.S. Energy Information Administration, more than 60% of the energy needed to generate electricity is lost in conversion. Even more energy is lost in power lines as electricity travels to NY communities. That’s a serious concern when you consider that much of New York’s electricity is generated in Canada. Learn more about how propane gas stacks up against electricity.

You’ve probably heard of Energy Star, the government-supported standard for energy efficiency. Energy Star ratings provide consumers with unbiased, straightforward information about energy efficiency for homes and businesses. This comes as a surprise to many people but it takes just 1.01 units of propane gas to produce and deliver a single unit of energy to a home, while that same unit of energy would require 3.03 units of electricity to get the same job done.

Energy Star Comparison:
Source site ratio